Monday, 23 June 2008

Aluminium / Steel Shoes in horse racing

Hi all,
As I go through some of the blogs of our colleagues, it seems lot of importance is given to this particular aspect. My understanding, experience & interaction with some of the trainers says, if it's going to be a tight finish, say a nose,shd,hd etc, even a diff of 50/100 gms in shoes weight will make the difference.But for horses which are far superior in class to others( Ex. MAM's wards ) it hardly matters. Here is an interesting article, which is by a famous farrier from Newzeland, which may be of interest to you.He quotes,
" Brent Jury has worked professionally as a farrier for 15 years, including stints overseas during which he has shod at the Badminton and Burghley international three-day-events, worked as a team farrier for the United States Equestrian Team, and as team farrier for the New Zealand eventing team at the World Equestrian Games in 2002. He explains the work of a farrier.
Everything a horse does, it does on its feet. No matter how well bred or how good their conformation, if their feet are of poor quality or structure, then the rest of the animal is compromised to some degree.
Because of human intervention in horse breeding, the process of "natural selection" no longer applies. As a result, we are not necessarily breeding the structural strength into horse's feet needed to cope with the forces that racing and other sports place on them. There are surprisingly few horses of any breed with perfect feet, although fortunately there are very few with extremely dysfunctional feet. Breeding, domestication, neglect and poor shoeing are all factors that may contribute to less than ideal feet. Given that the horse spent sixty million years evolving to its present form (without shoes on), shoeing carried out to the very best of a farrier's knowledge and ability still has, to some degree, a negative effect on hoof function.
But with specialist knowledge the farrier can help compensate for some of the short-falls that occur as a result of domestication. The basic reason for shoeing is that the horse wears down its feet faster than they grow. Anatomical and physical knowledge of the horse's legs and feet, coupled with an understanding of how the horse moves (biomechanics), as well as forging, shoeing skills, and horse sense are all elements needed to be an effective farrier.
Regular balanced hoof trimming and shoeing are essential to help achieve maximum locomotive output. On average, a racehorse needs shoeing every four to five weeks. Correct shoeing may help avoid damage to tendons, ligaments and joint structures of the lower leg. The higher the performance demanded of the horse, the higher the demands on their legs and feet. Consider, if we can increase a horse's stride length by 10mm for the same energy output, then we gain one metre over one hundred strides � a significant gain when a nose can be the difference between winning or coming second.
Most thoroughbreds race in aluminium shoes called plates. These are light and strong, and wear remarkably well. While most are shod with aluminium plates, a few still use light steel plates. Initially, when a horse first comes into work, a medium-weight steel shoe is used as this will both wear and support the foot well. The switch is made to aluminium plates once the horse's preparation has reached the stage of either trialling or racing. Aluminium plates are a fairly recent product, having been introduced within the last 20 or so years. Previously, horses were raced in lightweight steel shoes and worked in work shoes. These were interchanged when the horse raced, usually on race day. This was an added expense and also more damaging to the feet due to the extra nailing involved. Today, once the horse is racing they stay in their plates until they are worn out. At this time the feet also need to be trimmed and rebalanced.
The New Zealand Farriers Association (NZFA) has developed rules for shoeing, enforced by New Zealand Thoroughbred Racing. Each horse is inspected before its race by a designated plate inspector. These rules are not necessarily related to best shoeing practice. Rather they pertain more to the safety of the horse and jockey, and fairness to the racing public. Unlike a trotter, there are few "interference" problems at the gallop. Interference is when a horse strikes another leg mid-stride. At the gallop the toe of the leading front leg can sometimes come in contact with the diagonal back leg, an interference called speed cutting. There are ways that the farrier can shoe a horse to help prevent this. This usually involves making a variation to the shoes and/or the angles of the feet. Another problem is when the hind fetlocks distend down so far at the support phase of the stride that they come in contact with the ground, causing inflammation and skin breakage in this area. Some of the causes of stride-related problems may not necessarily come from the horse's feet, but can be due to incorrect conformation, or from the horse compensating for soreness somewhere else. This may even be soreness in the mouth; hence equine dentistry is also important.
I have been shoeing professionally for 15 years, and shoe for two of the South Island's more successful thoroughbred stables. However, my work also involves shoeing a variety of horses, including standardbreds, show jumpers, eventers, hunters, endurance and polo ponies, clydesdales, and even the odd donkey.
As a result of technology there are many different types of machine-made shoes available. This has considerably reduced the time spent hand-forging my own shoes, although I still make some specialist shoes that cannot be bought. Lameness from the feet or legs are specialist areas that I often deal with in conjunction with the veterinarian, and for which such specialised shoes might be made.
There are many products on the market that we can use to enhance hooves. One of the most useful is Equibond. This is a two-part mix that sets to the same consistency as the hoof wall and enables us to add to or repair hoof � a fairly recent innovation and a great concept as in the past we have only been able to remove hoof.
One of my roles is as an assessor and tutor for the NZFA, which has developed NZQA-registered units and courses that make up the Certified Farrier certification. Of concern is a lack of trainees undertaking these courses, which may result in fewer skilled farriers throughout the industry. For the benefit of the horse we need to encourage more of our young, horse-orientated people into the profession. "

3 comments:

KSP said...

Dear Madhu,

It all depends on the Track Conditions and how well the surface suits the horse.

There are trainers whose wards always
( 99 % ) WIN only on Alu Shoes.When the horse is not in JOB then a shift to Steel is made.You often notice a Horse winning on Alu Shoes and then in the next few outings there would be a negative change in equipment and the Horse would never even place.I can vouch for the accuracy of this view .

All Horses which run with ALUminium shoes may not WIN but i can confidently state that once a Horse wins on Alu Shoes , and then if there is a shift to Steel it invariably loses.

Some Horses WIN on Steel and then later the trainer may shift to ALU .It may or may not benefit the Horse .These are usually not commented .I always make a mention only if the reverse happens.

You can go through the records of Bangalore and Mumbai for the last 10 years to confirm to this view.

You can refer to the records of Trainers like Padmanabhan , Ganapathy , Darius Byramji , Dhariwal , Satish Narredu , Habib Khan , Arjun Mangalorkar , Irfan Ghatala etc and they always use the A Shoes.

In Western India , Shroff , Sunderji , Daji , Todywala , Karthik , I A Sait , C D Katrak all go by ALU and i cant recollect any of their mounts Winning on Alu and then repeating the feat with Steel.

A few like Byramji , Puttana , Lokanath Gowda and the rest in bangalore go with steel as well as ALU.In Western India the likes of Lagad , Jodha and the smaller trainers go with both Alu and Steel Shoes.

At the end of the day Steel or Aluminium may not matter if the Horse is really GOOD but since I always make of note of positive or negative change in equipment in my BLOG , i thought it fit to reply here.


There are one off cases in bangalore and i recollect right Sweeping Sucess , Mystical and a few others have WON with Steel shoes in the initial stages of their career.

The same may not hold good in some centres like Kolkatta , Hyderabad , Madras , Ooty and Mysore.

Shyam

madhu said...

Hi Shyam,
I dont deny the importance of ALUMIN shoes,they are leight weight & as I already mentioned,play important role in close finishes.
They are expensive for small time owner/trainer combination, as you have noticed, most of them will win with steel shoes.
In Mumbai most of the top trainers runners will be always in Aluminium.So winner picking is difficult based only on Shoe.It is difficult to arrive at a fair judgement of a probable winner.
I've gone through records of Bangalore winter & current Summer and also current Mysore summer record with reference to the winners only.Following statistics may shed some light on this matter.
Blore winter 07/08
Total winners 248
winners with AL shoes 185 ie 75%
- " - ST Shoes 63 ie 25%
Cur.Blore Sum 08
Total Winners till dt 92
winners with AL shoes 74 ie 80 %
-- " -- ST shoes 18 ie 20 %
As the season progresses, the percentages may catch up with winter figures.
Mysore Summer 08
Tot.Winners 49
Winner with Al shoes 19 ie 39 %
-- " -- ST shoes 30 ie 61 %
In Bangalore even a 25% winners with steel shoes is quite substantial & you can not neglect them & in Mysore it will be suicidal.
Regards.

Sunil said...

Hi Madhu,

Very good information. All these years, I was also thinking exactly what Shyam mentioned in his response to your article. Thanks for this very useful information.

I came to know about your blog in one on Shyam's Race Geniuss mail. I must also thank Shyam for sharing a lot of information.

Have a great day.
Sunil